Rev. Bruce Shipman, the Episcopal priest and former Chaplain at Yale, lives in a neighboring town. The controversy that surrounded his letter to the New York Times (August 21. 2014) concerning the rise of anti-Semitism in Europe caused his resignation from the Yale chaplaincy—and much by way of accusation and defense. Not surprisingly the issue has played out with prominence in the local newspaper, the Day of New London.

I must admit when I read his Times letter on the day it was published I thought that it would cause some strong responses, but I could not then see anything that could be construed as anti-Semitic. I read and re-read the letter once the controversy broke, and even after puzzling over the Day’s editorial taking Shipman to task, I could only just comprehend the nature of the outcry. Frankly, I worried over my own sensitivity to concerns for social and political justice. What was I missing?

In the letter written last Sunday in the Day,  Shipman points to the First Amendment issues clearly involved and, of course, the specific related concern for academic freedom. He also explains the effect that “the furor” he faces has upon his life and vocation. Likewise, regarding his vocation, Shipman makes clear the fundamental issue of “prophetic witness” that is part of his ministry. I think it only fair to honor his concern that “that subject” be brought into the light.